Club + Resort Chef

  • Home
  • Profiles
  • F+B
    • Culinary
    • Banquets
    • Pastry
    • Beverage
    • Recipes
  • Certification
  • 40 Under 40
    • 2027 Nomination Form
    • Class of 2026
    • Class of 2025
    • Class of 2024
    • Order: Commemorative Plaque
  • Films
    • Watch: Inside Ocean Reef
    • Watch: All Ships Rise
  • Resources
    • Reports + Playbooks
      • The Chef’s Table Cookbook
      • Make Yourself Hirable: A Playbook
      • Salary Survey Data
      • Grand Gatherings: The Banquet Cookbook
      • 2025: Hottest Food Trends
    • Master Class
    • C+R Talks
    • C+RC Association
    • Digital Issues
    • Submit Industry News
  • Chef to Chef
    • Register for Chef to Chef
    • Chef of the Year
    • Chef to Chef On Demand
  • Hall of Fame
    • Selection Process + Nomination Form
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe

Self-Reflection Does Not Replace Critical Feedback

By Lawrence McFadden, CMC, Global Hospitality Professional | January 18, 2022

The Union Club of Cleveland’s Lawrence McFadden, CMC, GM/COO, encourages club chefs to build a team of trusted advisors who will challenge their decisions and help guide their leadership.

Today, I walked the boiler room with our engineer of thirty-five years. Words like intake values, heat sensors, freshwater cycles, and backflow rolled out of his mouth so cavalierly. Honestly, I don’t know a darn thing he said, but I am grateful for his knowledge.

Chefs and engineers have many similarities. The chef is the culinary expert in any organization. Similar to engineers, the chef is the only one who truly understands the inner working of their department.

The way our engineer used those terms in our discussion sounded hauntingly familiar to the way I spoke as a chef. The only difference is that I would soften and minimize technical terms (and end the conversation by tasting something delicious).

When I would walk colleagues into the kitchen, they marveled at all the different staff members scurrying to keep pace. Our cooks were always serious, with their heads down, looking up with a respectful nod to these strangers when they visited.

One of my mentors, Ed Staros, Former Ritz-Carlton Vice President and Managing Director, said he would have loved being a chef and being a master of a craft. In his role, he saw himself as a manager of others’ mastery and felt most people could accomplish their roles without him. I would professionally disagree with his assessment, though. Ed was a master of people and of himself. He was humble and deeply intelligent. He also had an iron will when it came to quality.

In my current position as GM/COO of The Union Club of Cleveland, I have a new “boss” every two years. While these club presidents are masters of their professions, more often than not, “club president” is a new job title for them.

Giving up control or re-explaining operations is a normal challenge for each new term. Much like Staros (and our chef and engineer), operational excellence is my expertise.

Over the past six years, to keep myself trained on a north star, I have collected a key group of individuals who help guide my decisions and direction. These individuals represent the club industry, our membership, a professional community, and my worship group. Each is founded in a relationship of mutual respect and built on spiritual and business balance.

These advisors are certainly not individuals who are going to tell me what I want to hear. In fact, often they request I go back and re-think my views or a situation to find a better solution.

As a chef, you have a responsibility to create a clear vision for yourself and those on your team. Your staff must trust in the consistency, tact, moral and ethical approach you bring to all of your decision-making. A great leader owes the team their complete attention and a detailed, clear, identifiable process.

My advisors are not selected for consensus ideals. In fact, they are selected for the contrary. I want them to protect my decisions with contrasting views. If a problem is large or personal, I will engage in long detailed meetings with these advisors. The final decision always rests in my hands as the leader, but securing great guidance will most often secure consistent, confident results.

Our chef and I often discuss who his advisors are and when he should reach out to them. Most decisions in cooking are black or white, but in leadership, a fair process requires more insight, and “pause.” Almost like a “draft” email, an important decision must be reviewed or mentally read over numerous times.

Do you ever send a response without pause? Usually, these responses cause greater harm than resolution.

The great Billy Graham would write a letter in longhand as many as fifty times until the letter was soft enough to be understood and greeted with understanding. He once said, “I tip my pen in tears for my advisories so that the best decision for both can be made.”

As chefs we are the experts in culinary, but certainly not in the relationship of people. For that, we must be slow, methodical students. We must lean on our advisors and take the time to evaluate our decisions.

Great decisions are not about being right. They are about being fair and moral. As we continue to build teams and serve as mentors to those we hire, remember to build up your own set of advisors, pause and evaluate how your decisions will impact your team, and make certain they are well-vetted and for the greater good.

About The Author

Lawrence McFadden, CMC, Global Hospitality Professional

Lawrence T. McFadden, CMC, is a Master Chef and Global Hospitality Professional. He is the former General Manager/COO of the 146-year-old Union Club of Cleveland. His impressive 30-year career spans the globe with roles in Hong Kong and Singapore as well as some iconic operations state-side, including The Greenbrier, MGM Grand Hotel and Casino, The Ritz Carlton Company and The Waldorf Astoria Hotel.

Related Articles Read More >

Lawrence McFadden, CMC, HoF: What Fasting Has Taught Me
Is Honesty Always the Best Policy?
The Best Chefs I’ve Worked For Never Made You Feel Stupid for Asking
Staff Are the Organization’s Motivational Posters

PlateCraft

https://youtu.be/2FMew_1aY9A

Chef to Chef Conference

https://youtu.be/ROcThlUjh0Q?si=MJoLDtVG85tSBxgM

C+RC Newsletter

Club + Resort Chef Association

Elevate Your Club and Career: Join CRCA

C+RC Association Join the Club + Resort Chef Association to connect with a network of elite club culinary professionals and access exclusive resources and certifications designed to elevate your skills and career. Embrace the opportunity to showcase your talent, learn from industry leaders, and stay at the forefront of club culinary.

C+RC Digital Issues

Club & Resort Business Browse the latest and archived issues of the premier magazine for club and resort culinary teams, available in a user-friendly and high-quality format. Enjoy the convenience of bookmarking, sharing, and engaging with the top culinary content tailored for club and resort chefs.

Club + Resort Chef
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe
  • Recipes
  • Submit Industry News
  • Submit a Recipe
  • Club & Resort Business
  • Club & Resort Chef Association

Copyright © 2026 Arrowfly LLC. All Rights Reserved. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Arrowfly
Privacy Policy | Advertising | About Us

Search Club + Resort Chef

  • Home
  • Profiles
  • F+B
    • Culinary
    • Banquets
    • Pastry
    • Beverage
    • Recipes
  • Certification
  • 40 Under 40
    • 2027 Nomination Form
    • Class of 2026
    • Class of 2025
    • Class of 2024
    • Order: Commemorative Plaque
  • Films
    • Watch: Inside Ocean Reef
    • Watch: All Ships Rise
  • Resources
    • Reports + Playbooks
      • The Chef’s Table Cookbook
      • Make Yourself Hirable: A Playbook
      • Salary Survey Data
      • Grand Gatherings: The Banquet Cookbook
      • 2025: Hottest Food Trends
    • Master Class
    • C+R Talks
    • C+RC Association
    • Digital Issues
    • Submit Industry News
  • Chef to Chef
    • Register for Chef to Chef
    • Chef of the Year
    • Chef to Chef On Demand
  • Hall of Fame
    • Selection Process + Nomination Form
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe